The Brave New World of Student Teacher High-Stakes Evaluation, an update...

I read an excellent piece on the status of American education in The Atlantic recently, and would strongly recommend anyone interested in schools and schooling to click here and take a look at what Jack Schneider has to say about what's really happening in our schools.


On balance, Mr. Schneider offers a very fair and level-headed analysis of American public education, suggesting that the "crisis" in American education has been wildly exaggerated. But the real problem underlying this discussion can be seen in the first 2 paragraphs, in which only 3 persons are identified as “education experts”:


Sal Khan, Campbell Brown, and Michelle Rhee.

To be clear, none of these persons has attended a public school, has a degree in education, has had their children attend a public school, or has ever held teacher certification. And yet they possess the loudest and most strident voices in the education policy arena, dominating conversations on education policy through sheer volume, and absorbing much of the light and heat in the education policy sphere. Aided and abetted by "education publications" like the billionaire-funded Education Post, Brown has become the "moderator du jour" for education reform meetings, conferences, and made-for-TV edu-infomercials.


If the country desired a substantive discussion on health care policy, we wouldn’t turn to “Dr.” Laura, “Dr.” Phil and “Dr." J. 


We would convene task forces of actual physicians and medical researchers, have meaningful discussions on health care policy and practices, and make reasoned, incremental changes in these policies and practices.


But in education, we have allowed edutourists like Rhee and Campbell to be elevated to positions of authority, and technocrats like Khan to be lauded as visionaries, even as the research conducted by actual education experts is ignored, scorned and even repudiated, and replaced with ideas designed to privatize schools, demonize teachers, and profitize children.


Now, even some of these education experts, tempted by the prospect of previously unimaginable wealth and power, have sold out their profession for a shot at cashing in on the corporate reform gravy train. Witness Dr. Deborah Ball’s stepping down as Dean of the School of Education at the University of Michigan to concentrate on her work on NOTE: National Observational Teaching Examination for ETS, the Educational Testing Service.


As I've written about previously here, and here, and others have written about here, NOTE is a high-stakes student teacher evaluation test that requires pre-service teachers to "instruct" avatars--yes, avatars! And if their "teaching" of these cartoon characters isn't deemed adequate, the student teacher is denied their certification or teaching license, in spite of the fact that the student teacher in question has just completed an accredited, rigorous 4 or 5 year teacher preparation program, regardless of the student teacher's earned GPA or demonstrated capability to teach real, live children in hundreds of hours of field experiences in local school classrooms, or the intern's exhibited knowledge, understanding or competence in their subject area.


(And, just to rub a little salt in the wound: the persons who are remotely-operating the avatars are not teachers themselves--they are unemployed actors who have been trained to manipulate the joy sticks and computer simulations that control the avatars' voices and movements. The designers of the avatar system found that teachers thought too much about their responses to the interns' teaching "moves"--the actors didn't concern themselves with matters like content correctness or developmentally-appropriate responses; they just followed the provided script, and efficiently completed the task at hand.)


As Jack Schneider points out in his article, 

If the educational system had broken at some point, a look backward would reveal an end to progress—a point at which the system stopped working. Yet that isn’t at all the picture that emerges. Instead, one can see that across many generations, the schools have slowly and steadily improved.



The truth, unfortunately, is much less sexy, and doesn't sell nearly as many newspapers or generate as many "clicks".


It's not very exciting to suggest that our schools, even as they have been systematically defunded by federal and state governments, are doing a terrific job of educating the nation's children.


It doesn't create much "buzz" to point out that even in spite of constantly moving targets, fluctuating "cut scores" on standardized tests, and daily changes to state teacher evaluation systems, our teachers are better prepared than they have ever been, are being expected to do more with less, and--amazingly--are doing it.


America's educational system is not "broken", and our schools aren't "failing." Our teachers aren't "lazy," and no, Sec. Duncan: our kids aren't "dumb."

The truth is that the vast majority of American schools are excellent, and our teachers are doing heroic work under the most difficult working conditions we have seen in our lifetimes. Our education system isn't "failing": we have failed our schools.


The solution to getting out of the "manufactured crisis" we now find ourselves in starts with listening to the real education experts in our midst: the classroom teachers who have devoted their professional lives to teaching our children.

And politely telling Mr. Khan, Ms. Brown and Ms. Rhee to mind their own business, and let us do our jobs.

Write a comment

Comments: 10
  • #1

    Anne Tenaglia (Monday, 27 June 2016 07:46)

    I so agree with this. It is ridiculous that the politicians won't even consider consulting REALLY teachers at various levels of the K-12 spectrum to see what things have merit and those that don't. , or to do multiple years of field testing before implementing changes in curriculum, presentation and methods.

  • #2

    Duane Losey (Wednesday, 29 June 2016 11:08)

    Thank you for writing this piece. Please keep M.S.U. 'in line' with what's best for the educational field and not for corporations/private enterprise.

  • #3

    Russ Walsh (Wednesday, 29 June 2016 11:23)

    Outstanding piece Mitchell. I can't stand it when so-called education "experts" are given press for their self-serving ideas. Unfortunately, the real experts are silenced by these chicken littles. It is even more disturbing when one of our own, like Dr. ball go over to the dark side. I experienced this in my field, literacy, when many fine literacy professors and researchers put their names to basal readers. The current move to undermine schools of education is just one more front on the on-going war to save our profession from the corporate raiders.

  • #4

    CBD Oil (Friday, 18 August 2017 18:26)

    howdy, your websites are really good. I appreciate your work.

  • #5 (Wednesday, 18 October 2017 08:28)

    This is a great post. I like this topic.This site has lots of advantage.I found many interesting things from this site. It helps me in many ways.Thanks for posting this again.

  • #6

    CheatEngine (Friday, 22 December 2017 04:45)

    The majority of the preferred video games are prone to this device and also they could be hacked conveniently. If you want to attain greater degrees without battling, after that this application could aid you.

  • #7

    asesoria de imagen (Tuesday, 26 December 2017 08:26)

    Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot.

  • #8

    Mual (Wednesday, 27 December 2017 00:31)

    Saat Ku Mengenalmu

  • #9

    Biomedical Engineering Projects (Saturday, 22 September 2018 01:52)

    biomedical projects for ece biomedical projects ideas biomedical projects 2018
    biomedical projects using arduino

  • #10

    google (Tuesday, 06 November 2018 01:33)

    good post